Medical Radiation – Neutrons vs Protons

NEUTRONS vs PROTONS

 

NEUTRONS

PROTONS

Type of particle

Neutral, mass=1

Positively charged, mass=1 

Production [high energy]
(iThemba)

Nuclear reactions [40-70 MeV protons or deuterons on beryllium]
(66 MeV protons)

Accelerator beams [>150  MeV]
(200 MeV)

Interactions with tissue

Nuclei (mainly hydrogen)

Electrons 

No. of centres

5
(2 high-energy)

34
(6 low energy) 

Beam delivery

(iThemba)

Vertical, horizontal, mainly isocentric beams. [Fixed, variable, multileaf collimators] 
(Isocentric, variable collimator, multiblade trimmer)

Mainly horizontal, vertical, isocentric beams; passive, active beam spreading. [Fixed, multileaf collimators] 
(Horizontal, fixed collimators)

Major clinical advantage

Biological effect
[large, slow-growing lesions] 

Dose distribution
[lesions close to critical structures] 

No. of patients treated wordwide
(iThemba)

40 000 (estimated)

(1690)

67097

(511)

No. of fields
(iThemba)

1 – 6
(1 – 8)

1 – 12
(1 – 5)

No. of 
treatments
(iThemba)

12 – 20

12

1 – 36

(1 – 5)

Lesions
* definite cure for most cases 

(Malignant only)
Salivary gland*, paranasal sinus,
head and neck, soft tissue sarcoma*,
uterine sarcoma, prostate * ,
melanoma, bone tumour, breast 

(Benign and malignant) 
Uveal melanoma*, pituitary adenoma * , meningioma*, prostate,
arteriovenous malformation * , cervix, acoustic neuroma*,
paranasal sinus, chondrosarcoma *

Top of Page

From the Director’s Office

A New Year brings new opportunities to share a vision, build collaborations and shape the future.

Read more

Corporate Profile

Corporate profile of iThemba LABS in February issue of Leadership Magazine p. 68-69

Read more p. 68-69

SA-CERN Collaboration

Big data science in South Africa reaching new funding highs through the South African CERN collaboration

Read more ...

ATLAS upgrade workshop

News Archive